Judging of the Spirit Award is based on the demonstration of Scout Spirit, Patrols, and the Troop as embodied in the Scout Oath, Scout Law, Scout Motto, and the Scout Slogan. The specific actions of each Scout need to be considered along with how well the Troop and the Patrols work together. Important points to consider are the effectiveness of Scout leadership in the Patrol and how well the leaders set the example for the rest of the Troop. Some things to look for in judging the Troops are:

Are they prepared for the event or activity?
Did everyone participate in the event or activity?
Do they work as an effective group?
Are they properly uniformed?
Do they show "esprit de corps"?
Are all the scouts doing their part?
Are the Scouts and their area clean?
Are they on time?
Are they having a good time?
Was a GOOD TURN done? (THIS IS IMPORTANT)
Was the Outdoor Code followed?
Were things done safely?
Are they courteous to each other and to others?
Were quiet times observed?
Were the regulations of the Camporee followed?

Judging the positive aspects of each Unit is preferred. Negative aspects should be considered but not emphasized. Troop size is not a factor in judging Troops.